I absolutely have to make a Boeuf en Croute, comedy demands it.
I grew up with the classic comedies, and I have spent some time re-viewing all of them lately. I’ve seen entire series from The Dick Van Dyke Show, The Mary Tyler Moore Show and several spin-offs, Frasier and Wings (although I never liked Cheers), Gilligan’s Island, It’s About Time, and basically everything that defines comedy from the year I was born to present (for present: The Big Bang Theory, Sh*t My Dad Says, …).

In nearly every comedy there’s a point where someone astonishes the rest of the cast by being a gourmet chef, or at least prepares an impressive gourmet dinner with comedic results. In all cases the grand impressive entrée is some kind of meat inside some kind of bread or pastry. The classic dish from The Mary Tyler Moore Show (The Dinner Party, Season 4, Episode 10) was Veal Prince Orloff,which is a braised loin of veal, thinly sliced, filled with a thin layer of pureed mushrooms and onions between each slice, and stacked back and then topped with bechamel sauce and cheese and browned in the oven. What was seen onscreen looked more like Beef Wellington. You hear a lot of references to Beef Wellingtion on TV and in movies. Beef Wellington is a preparation of fillet steak coated with pâté (often pâté de foie gras) and duxelles, which is then wrapped in puff pastry and baked. Veal Prince Orloff is also mentioned in the Wings episode It’s So Nice to Have a Mather Around the House (Season 4, Episode 7) when the stars are anticipating their lunches “… I can’t wait to see what Lowell made us for lunch today,” “He’s going to have to go a long way to beat yesterday’s veal prince orloff…”
I don’t think I’ll ever make a Veal Prince Orloff for several reasons. First of all I have a bit of an aversion to veal that I won’t go into here (except to say that aside from any emotional or political reasons to avoid veal I’ve found it bland and tasteless the few times I’ve had it). I don’t think mushrooms and onions benefit from being pureed – I think Prince Orlov would have been better served if his brazed veal was presented with sliced onions caramelized and sliced mushrooms browned in butter.
On the other hand, I’d really like to try a Beef Wellington, but again I doubt I’d ever want to prepare one. I don’t have a problem with pâté de foie gras per se, but it seems rather expensive and a lot of bother for something to spread on a lump of beef and then bake inside a pastry shell. It just seems like the pâté would be wasted – save it to use as a cold spread, you’ll never taste it in the Beef Wellington. And don’t get me started on pâté, the nearest thing to pâté I’ve had is an American version of haggis … and I liked it. But I digress …
Anyway – as a bachelor, and an American engineer of English/Scottish/Irish/German descent, it is comedically necessary that I prepare some really impressive meals that you would expect from your grandmother at worst, and a gourmet chef at best. I’ve already made a darned good roast turkey with some impressive side dishes. Yes, I have successfully roasted a whole turkey, made giblet gravy, admittedly the stuffing was of the stovetop variety, I’ve mashed potatoes (and yes, starting from whole potatoes, not flakes), steamed green beans, steamed carrots, prepared crudités (carrots, celery, cauliflower, broccoli, radishes)…
But comedy demands that I make some kind of beef inside a pastry to be surprisingly more domestic than the average bachelor. I have to make a Boeuf en Croute. As far as I can tell that basically means I need to get a decent boneless roast, probably a tenderloin, braze the roast and then cool it and set it aside, make the pastry, wrap the pastry around the roast, put the whole thing back in the oven so the roast cooks evenly before the pastry is burned to a cinder. That’s comedy? Sounds like a lot of work … I think I’ll stick to soups, chili, sandwiches, grilled stuff …
